Welcome to Casa Vieja - Brentwood, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Brentwood, New York. Known for its authentic Colombian cuisine, this charming restaurant invites you to embark on a flavorful journey that captures the essence of Colombian culture. Located at 1768 Brentwood Rd, Casa Vieja showcases a vibrant menu filled with traditional dishes that celebrate the rich culinary heritage of Colombia.
As you step inside, you’ll immediately feel the warmth and nostalgia that envelops the space, reminiscent of a cozy Colombian home. The ambiance is inviting, making it the perfect spot for family gatherings or intimate dinners with friends. The attentive service, highlighted by friendly staff who go the extra mile, ensures you feel right at home from the moment you arrive.
The menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, starting from Para Antes appetizers like the El Maduro Con Queso Y Carne, a delightful combination of yellow plantains stuffed with cheese and savory meat, to the popular Las Empanadas, which offer a crispy, comforting experience with every bite. For a heartier option, dive into the Bandeja Paisa, a must-try dish that showcases a medley of flavors and textures, ensuring a feast fit for kings.
Don’t miss out on the daily soups, ranging from Sopas Grande to Sopas Pequeno, which offer a warming touch that is deeply appreciated by guests. Reviewers have praised the freshness and generous portions of the dishes, often leaving them with satisfied smiles and memories worth cherishing.
Some guests have highlighted the experience of sharing products like Mofongo and Chicharrón with loved ones, creating an intimate atmosphere with comfort food that hits all the right notes. Whether it’s a family dinner or a simple meal with friends, Casa Vieja provides an experience that transcends mere dining and transforms it into cherished moments.
If you’re in search of a delightful escape to Colombia without leaving Brentwood, look no further than Casa Vieja. Come and savor the robust flavors, comforting dishes, and a warm atmosphere that will surely make you want to return time and again. We promise, your palate will thank you!
For reservations or more information, you can reach them at +1 631-434-8255. Dive into the heart of Colombian cuisine at Casa Vieja - a culinary experience you won’t forget!
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
23 Romilly St, London W1D 5AQ, United Kingdom
Inside Travel America, 10679 Lancaster Rd, Hebron, OH 43025, United States
Av. Corrientes 5588, C1414 AJV, Cdad. Autonoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina
24 Av. de Fontainebleau, 94270 Le Kremlin-Bicetre, France
Piazza del Mercato Nuovo, 18/r, 50123 Firenze FI, Italy
J F
05/10/2025
Everyone is rarely home at the same time so we decided to have a family dinner at Casa Vieja. I believe Dennis was our server and he did a good job handling our large group. I had the La Milanesa which is a breaded beef steak that comes with French fries. I washed that down with a couple of glasses of Sangria. It was an enjoyable meal and I would come again to try something else.
M K
23/09/2025
Made me feel right at home Sharing this food with my friends and family was wonderful. Mofongo, Chicharrón, Arepas, Empandas, Maduro, Bandeja Paisa, all so delicious. Their rice was so delicious. I grew up eating Colombian and it was just an overall very comforting experience. Must try restaurant!
Annie Kidd
23/09/2025
Such a beautiful small Latin food spot. Food was fresh and delicious. Big portions and friendly staff members. Definitely recommend
Aank Sandoval
13/09/2025
I visited this restaurant with my aunt, she's likes the beef empanadas they make, I tried the salmon and it was delicious and well cooked, everything look like an old Colombian house which is the theme of the place. I think that their customer service should improve a lot.
M B
06/08/2025
This place is awesome!! This is the second time I came here with my son. Great service great food. The amount of food they give you is unbelievable, a feast!!!
Lenny
06/08/2025
The food here is super fresh and full of flavor. Everything we ordered tasted homemade, and you can tell they put care into it. The place itself has a nice, relaxed vibe, it is simple but stylish decor that makes you feel comfortable. The staff was really friendly too, which made the whole experience even better. I’ve been looking for a good local spot, and I think this might be it. I’ll definitely be coming back. I recommend this place to everyone.
Kamil S
04/08/2025
Fresh and tasty Latin food. Decor was also pleasant. I think this will be my spot for now on.
Elaine McWilliams
21/07/2025
Love this place. The food portions are very large the service is great. The for money you get what you pay for and then some.